The Match Before Christmas

Title: The Match Before Christmas
Author: Eden Winters
Publisher: Rocky Ridge Books
Buy link: (Second Edition)
Genre:  Contemporary M/M, Holiday
Length: Short Story (14K / 57 pdf pages)
Rating:  4.5 stars out of 5

A Guest Review by Cole

Review Summary: A hilarious take on modern dating and one man’s naive determination that no matter how many bad dates he goes through, Mr. Right is just around the corner.


Candlelight, mistletoe, gaily wrapped packages beneath a trimmed tree, and someone to share it with. That’s all Barry Richards wants for Christmas. Desperate for a traditional holiday, he takes drastic measures. Creating a profile on “,” he hopes to find the perfect man in a matter of weeks. One date after another goes sour, while all around him friends are falling in love, and Barry starts to lose faith.

The first snow falls and the world is filled with seasonal cheer, all except for Barry, for whom time is running out. Facing the prospect of a lonely holiday, he tries just once more to make The Match Before Christmas.


After learning that his parents are spending this Christmas on a cruise, Barry is bummed to be missing his favorite holiday and the comfortable traditions they share. Not wanting to intrude on his sister and her husband’s Christmas without their parents there, Barry sets out to make his own Christmas wish — that when the holidays roll around, he will be able to show off his perfect boyfriend. The boyfriend that exists in Barry’s head is so perfect, that when he signs up for an account at, he has no doubt whatsoever that he’ll end up just like the beautiful, muscle hunks on the website offering their testimonials. What follows is Barry’s adventures through date after date of just about all of the worst men he could possibly be alone with: the man on the rebound, the married man, the man looking only for sex, and several other hilarious examples. He learns quite a bit with each date that leaves him unsatisfied, having been quite naive in the romance department. By the time he is about to give up, he starts to realize that maybe if he can’t find the perfect guy, he can find the perfect guy for someone else. Adding a human touch to the impersonal data dump that is the online dating pool, Barry starts to become a matchmaker himself. And maybe, if he pays it forward, someone good will come to him?

I have to tell you that I laughed out loud so many times reading this story. Barry has a really unique voice that is snarky at the same time as being incredibly innocent. Every date he went into with blind eyes I wanted to grab him up before he really got himself into a mess. I especially loved that he could easily have been portrayed as stupid or immature, but he wasn’t. He’s highly intelligent, but because he had been focused on work, he’s almost like a teenager dating for the first time. He is also an average Joe, slightly chubby with a nice face. He is very modest and at times I wondered if he was really a hunk, but because of self-depreciation thought he was ugly. The writing here is excellent as well, very witty. For example, throughout a meal with a much younger man who keeps bemoaning the loss of an ex named Jeff:

At the end of the meal, Barry’s curiosity finally got the better of him. “What happened to Jeff, if you don’t mind my asking?”

“Oh, he was found beaten to death in his apartment a month ago. But don’t worry; I’ve been cleared as a suspect.”

Barry raised his hand, frantically gesturing for the server. “Check, please!”

The only thing I thought could have been improved a bit was the amount of on-screen time Barry gets with Mr. Right once he’s found him.  The ratio of pre-boyfriend and post-boyfriend Barry was off.  It seemed like his search was so long and fruitless and then when he finally meets the right guy, we only get a few scenes of them together.  I wanted to see them revel in their happiness a bit while we got to know them better. Maybe if we had seen the scene with Barry’s family at the end…   Otherwise, I really loved this story.  Barry was a really engaging character who I would love to see again and again. He should have his own chronicle of adventures 🙂

Highly Recommended. Enjoy.


26, male, gay, baker, knitter, sometimes writer, and voracious reader of all things | contact me: cole.riann[at]


Hi Cole, wanted to let you know I picked this up after reading your review. Definitely needed a laugh, and it’s great to read a NICE guy for a change of pace. =D


Great review, Cole. I recommend Eden’s Angel of Thirteenth Street, The Wish, and The Telling. And anything else she writes!! Go Eden!!


Hey Cole,
I love funny stories, and Eden’s other books were so good that I’m sure I’ll enjoy this one. Thanks and great review!


Wow, Cole! You’ve made me extremely happy. I’m so glad you and the posters liked the story. Thanks, ya’ll.

A sequel? I hadn’t really thought about one until reading the comments here, then Barry grabbed one ear and Adam grabbed the other and started whispering(okay, they were actually screaming)ideas to me.

Thanks again for the kind words. They ease the pain of the horrifying dates I went on as research for this story.

Josephine Myles

Great review, Cole. I really like the sound of this one 🙂

PD Singer

Dating hell — no wonder he wanted out! Much funnier when it’s happening to someone else, and the end was sweet.


Sounds fun Cole….I am adding to my TBB list right now. Great review, I can’t wait to “meet” Barry.

Val Kovalin

I’m looking forward to reading this! Thanks, Cole. 🙂


I´ve read all her books so far and enjoyed them very much – especially The Wish.
This new one sounds like a great read, too. But its only 57 pages ;-( Maby there´s a sequel planned?


I loved this one. I gave it an A+. 🙂 I thought Barry was such a great character. Great review and I hope others check it out.


This sounds delightful. As you may have guessed, I love humour in M/M stories because the guys, no matter how stupid, insecure, etc., don’t come across as total pricks. Barry sounds like just the type of hero I would enjoy and I like Eden’s writing as well so this one is definitely headed to the TBR pile.

Thank you for this rec. I would never have found this book otherwise. 🙂


I love humor in books and this one sounds like a fab read. Thanks for the great review, Cole! 🙂

%d bloggers like this: