Pirates of the Narrow Seas Book 1: The Sallee Rovers

Title: Pirates of the Narrow Seas Book 1: The Sallee Rovers
Author: M. Kei
Publisher: Bristlecone Pine Press
Buy link: Amazon.com
Genre: m/m historical romance
Length: 284 pages
Rating: 4 stars out of 5

A guest review by Jenre

Summary Review
Ahoy, me hearties! This swashbuckling tale of a pirate and an uptight naval officer excelled in the relationship between the characters but lost me in all the nitty gritty details of life on a ship.

THE BLURB

Lieutenant Peter Thorton is in love with fellow lieutenant Perry. Both men are given commissions to serve aboard HMS Ajax, taking an Islamic envoy to talks in France. Thorton makes an enemy of the Captain, who is largely incompetent but does not like people who show they know it. During a storm, the Ajax comes to the rescue of a sinking Spanish galley. The Spanish abandon their vessel, leaving their slaves, chained to the oars, to sink with the ship. Thorton and several of the other British sailors attempt to free the slaves and stop the galley from sinking. As they do so, the storm blows the two ships apart, leaving him surrounded by freed slaves who have no desire to voluntarily sail back to the Ajax to be reunited with their captors.

Command of the galley is taken by Isam bin Hamet al-Tangueli (Captain Tangle to his crew) a famous pirate of the Barbary coast, who had been serving as a galley slave following capture by the Spanish. The story then follows Thorton’s slow naturalization into the ways of the Sallee Rovers, and his growing understanding that he’s better off in a culture that allows him to love other men without censure. Rejected by Perry and wooed by Tangle, Thorton has to decide where his loyalty really lies.

THE REVIEW

I’ve not read an ‘Age of Sail’ historical before, but I do have a deep and abiding love of Johnny Depp Pirates of the Caribbean. When I saw this had a similar theme – that of charismatic pirates, uptight naval officers, fighting and other assorted high-jinks on the ocean, I thought I’d give it a go and see what I thought. In the end this was a mixed read, for reasons I shall explain.

Peter Thorton (which for some reason I kept reading as Thornton), is a relatively new Lieutenant in the British Navy. He’s thrilled when he’s given a commission with his best friend Roger Perry, with whom he is secretly in love, on a boat carrying a Sallee diplomat to the south of France. Things don’t go too well for Peter, who is naturally taciturn but who also likes to use his initiative – something that does not endear him to the Captain who is a stickler for rules and regulations. When a rescue attempt of a sinking Spanish galley goes wrong, Peter is left stranded on the galley with a number of freed slaves which includes the handsome and charismatic Sallee privateer, Captain Tangle. Peter is torn between his admiration for the Captain, and his sense of honour and duty to the King’s navy.

As this book is a historical and most of the action takes place on various boats/ships, there’s a lot of detail of the day to day running of a ship and lengthy descriptions of what the ship looks like, how the sails are put up/down, the different ranks/jobs of the men who sail the ship, and various other tiny details about ship life. Those of you who love boats/ships, especially those from the past, are going to be absolutely delighted by the sheer amount of detail you get about life on the ocean wave. If, like me, you’re completely clueless about boats/ships and aren’t really that interested in the minutiae of ship-life, then you may just find all this description a bit dull. I did. Not only that but I found all the ship vocabulary very confusing and simply couldn’t picture in my head where the poop deck was, or what a mizzen or a jib were. This meant that often I could only get the impression that something exciting was happening by the large number of baffling orders being shouted out, rather than being able to picture what was happening on deck. The same was the case with the battle scenes, which are intricately orchestrated, as you can imagine when there’s two ships trying to get in position to blast each other out of the water. However, because I didn’t have the knowledge, I couldn’t imagine the scene in my head, so it was all just a lot of words with little meaning.

Fortunately, as well as all the action on deck, there’s a really good personal story going on alongside the description. It was this part of the book which had me hooked. The character of Peter was well rounded and I liked his slight aloofness which hid an honourable man who just wanted to get on with being the best officer he could. The book was at its best when Peter is interacting with the other characters. Thus I felt all his frustration at his superior when Peter is punished for showing good sense instead of following orders to the letter; his powerful yearning for Roger and his despair at knowing that Roger could never love him back; and his confusion when faced with the dilemma of betraying his country or following a man he admires and respects. I also liked the way that the British Navy is compared to the more laid back approach of the Sallee Rovers, and how that appeals to Peter. Finally, I liked Captain Tangle, who is larger than life, and could see why Peter finds him so attractive.

I feel I ought to mention, for those who don’t like such things, that Tangle is a married man. This causes a lot of tension between Peter and Tangle during the book. Personally, I thought this was resolved very satisfactorily, but I know some readers don’t like infidelity in which case you may not like this book.

Overall, if you love ‘Age of Sail’ books then you’ll probably really like this. In the end, it was the romance and the tensions between characters which was the book’s biggest draw for me – enough that I’m looking forward to the next book.

16 comments

  • See, I am going to be writing something for them come November when I am done with my other deadlines and finding that line between historical accuracy and human interaction has me just a tad anxious…

    Too bad I can’t talk to you while writing it! *G*

    I’ll want a good review and I am excited about this story..! 🙂

    Reply
    • Ah, I can see why you might be feeling anxious :). Good luck with your book. In the end you just have to write what seems true and good to you and hope that us readers will like it.

      Reply
  • Coming late to this review, but just wanted to say ‘thanks’ – I’ll be putting this on my things to read list. Even being someone who grew up on a diet of Swallows & Amazons and sailing with my family most weekends in the summer doesn’t stop me from getting overload from some authors’ depth of nautical detail, so if you found you could still follow and enjoy the story, hopefully I will too!

    Reply
  • I have heard so many good things about this publisher and how they go to great lengths to be accurate in their period pieces.

    I know from experience that when writing a story that is period, you will be JUMPED all over for making the tiniest mistake. A friend of mine for instance wrote a story with barbwire that took place two years before there was barbwire and still hears about it over a decade later.

    Isn’t accuracy part of period pieces?

    I would love to hear more thoughts on this…

    Reply
    • Hi BG

      You’re right in a way, authors are damned if they do attempt to get all the details right and damned if they don’t! There will be some readers who love age of sail books and will read this one expecting a high level of detail. In which case this book will be very satisfying for them. Personally, I read the book for the human interaction and found the detail a little dull, but this was still a great book and worth reading.

      I think it’s still possible to be accurate in your setting without overwhelming the reader, but maybe not so much for books set on a ship with hundreds of technical/sailing words and such a busy atmosphere.

      Reply
  • I thought this story was really, really good. I agree about the detailed description of the boats/sailing/battle but I just skimmed through it. The characters and the story were very interesting though. Unusual.

    Reply
    • Hi Chris

      As I was reading this, I was thinking that this book probably wouldn’t appeal to you :). Sadly, Johnny Depp doesn’t appear in the book, but Captain Tangle is a more than adequate substitute :).

      Reply
  • I agree with you about the sheer amount of boat vocabulary which went completely over my head most of the time. But really a good read with well developped characters, i was hooked. love the second one too.

    Reply
    • I have a different take on the nautical detail. I never once in all of the description felt that I missed anything that I needed to know, and I also felt that since the ship and the sea are the whole world to these men it was appropriate to soak us in it. What the nautical detail did for me was give me a sense of their lives and what mattered to them.

      Reply
      • Hi Nan

        Oh, I agree, the complexity of the descriptions did immerse you in the setting, and had they not been there the story wouldn’t have felt as authentic as it did, but I still found it a little dull because of my own lack of knowledge about nautical matters. Readers who love boats/ships will have entirely the opposite reaction to me and will love all the detail.

        Reply
    • Hi Obsalys

      Yes, the character development was superb. I loved reading about Peter’s internal struggles between duty and his desire to serve under Captain Tangle.

      Reply

Please comment! We'd love to hear from you.

%d bloggers like this: