Two Sides of the Same Coin (Lucky Jeff Ranch #1)

Title: Two Sides of the Same Coin (Lucky Jeff Ranch #1)
Author: Jake Mactire
Buy link:
Genre: Contemporary Romance/Western/D/s-lite
Length: Novel (341 PDF pages)
Rating: 3.5 stars out of 5

A Guest Review by Aunt Lynn

One Sentence Review: Though not without issues, a decent first effort by a writer that shows promise.

This review contains what could be considered spoilers


Leaving his boyfriend behind in San Francisco, cowboy and struggling artist Jeff Connelly returns to the family ranch after his father’s death and meets the man who will become a large part of his future: ranch hand Mike Guidry. Mike starts out cynical, bitter, and very unfriendly, but he warms to Jeff when he realizes Jeff just might be the friend he needs.

Life on the ranch is as hard as Jeff remembers: he has to deal with cattle rustling and the stress of hoping the business will break even while he weathers changes in attitude from the locals, harassment, prejudice, and betrayal. Jeff and Mike will embark on a plan to secure the ranch’s future, try to find a way to live and love together, and discover that they’re more alike than they’d ever have dreamed.

Lucky Jeff Ranch Series


Two Sides of the Same Coin seems to be the first published story by this author. With a healthy page count, an interesting blurb and a nice cover, I was hoping for a winner as I was in the mood for a western. But while decently written and ambitious, like other books that failed to meet my expectations recently, it was laced with problems for me. I think that a lot of it comes from inexperience, and I anticipate that with some more writing under his belt, Mactire could become a good author.

Jeff returns to his homestead cattle ranch in a valley in the North Cascades of Washington State after the death of his father, to the displeasure of his San Francisco boyfriend, Robert. He is needed at the ranch, and besides, he’s more comfortable there than anywhere else because even though he is an artist with an accounting degree, he’s really a cowboy at heart. When he gets there, he finds new hand Mike, a grumpy, anti-social man with whom not many get along, a challenge. Mike does his job and well, but no one wants to be around him. After some time, Jeff is able to bring him out of his shell and befriend him, thus learning of Mike’s difficult past as a gay youth in a very strict, religious family. Once Jeff is free from Robert, he cautiously, but happily enters into a relationship with Mike, with whom he has tons more in common than any of his other boyfriends and is very attracted. In the meantime, he has big, dangerous problems with rustlers and fears that the ranch won’t be able to stay afloat financially. With new ventures in the works and the acceptance of the town folks, he has hopes that it will all work out with the man he loves.

What worked for me:

I thought the characters were likeable, realistic and well-developed, and I really liked watching the interaction between the cast of friends who are more like family than not. I thought the plot was believable, and though I suspected the reveal very early on — and I was right — the rustlers mystery was a good touch, taking the edge somewhat off what could have been a highly saccharin romance (see more on this later).

What didn’t:

As I said, this book has a healthy page count and with almost 170k words, it’s very dense. That should be good, but for me it wasn’t, and what I found were multiple things that could have been dealt with tighter editing. It seemed, to me, to be just too…much.

First are the many info dumps. Several characters — especially (but not limited to) Jeff — turn conversations into huge explanations about lots of topics, from what it’s like to be an out gay man, to what it’s like to be a cowboy and/or rancher, to what rodeos (straight and gay ones as well) are like, to the differences between cultures, to how to do art, to Wicca and its ceremonies and other religious views. Although I learned some things, it was tedious as a reader for these long enlightenment episodes and at times I felt like I was being lectured.

Related to this, it’s quite heavy in dialog, and while I love to watch characters interact via spoken word, many things are said repeatedly. I grew weary of the number of times we hear “buddy,” “Jeffy,” “buckaroo” and other nick-namies as well as how Jeff’s dad would approve of their relationship and how he felt about Mike, how the characters all feel about each other, how big Jeff’s member is, cowboy coffee, and “son of a bitch stew,” just to name a few things.

Next, it is extremely — too much, for my tastes — descriptive. We get deep details on most meals, drinks, clothing, songs that are played or sung (and sometimes their words), chores that are being done, dancing and other social gatherings (of which there are many).

Outside of the initial issues with Mike’s reserved stand-offishness, all of the conflict is external. Our heroes get along like bread and butter and don’t have any problems to work through. It made it overly sweet in spots. Also, there’s a lot of smexxin and much of it is repetitive. I ended up skimming through most of the scenes, looking for things that were either different or would lead to a furthering of the plot.

I found Jeff to be very Gary-Sue-ish: he’s handsome, well-built, hung like a horse, can fuck like a champion, seems to be good at whatever he puts his mind to, is a real charmer and just about everyone loves him on sight. Related to this, the ranch and town around it are like gay utopia. Outside of a very few predictable bigots, gays are accepted by just about everyone in the town, and even rooted for. And it seems like this is one of those tales where quite a few of the straight characters conveniently have a gay relative.


While not without issues for me, Two Sides of the Same Coin is an ambitious first effort. I am interested to see what this author produces next.


  • Hello Aunt Lynne Thank YOU first of all for the review. it made me read this one.
    Just finished reading it and I LOVED it.. I agree the characters developed well and their “family” had great interaction.I also thought he did a fantastic job making me dislike Robert… But I did not find it to be overly descriptive at all.. Not having any experience with a wicca ceremony or a gay rodeo I enjoyed the info and that it was broken up throughout the story instead of a block of info kept it intriguing. I a found it endearing that the guys kept using Jeffy and Buddy as it turned each of them on to hear it… As for the sex scenes I wanted to go find myself a Jeffy (just the opinion of a gay man):) Hopefully Jake Mactire will have more for Mike and Jeff as this was a great beginning..

  • Hi Lynn, thanks for a wonderful review. I imagine that this was a difficult one to write, what with all the problems you had with it while still being interested in the author in general. I hadn’t planned on this book really, just because it didn’t seem to diverge at all from the typical cowboy love story with townsfolk dangers. There are so many books written on that premise that a new one has to be really exceptional to stand out.

  • Lynn

    because even though he is an artist with an accounting degree, he’s really a cowboy at heart

    This would have been the first clue for me. lol

    I read through your list of what you didn’t like and I’m surprised that you persevered with this book after you reached the half way mark.

    A new author teamed with probably an inexperienced editor (I’m making an assumption here b/c I can’t see an experienced editor allowing all the repetition and info dumps) do not make for a well written book. This could probably have been trimmed down to 200 pages with all the info dumps and everything that really was not germane to the story taken out.

    I think you were really kind in your rating, with all the problems associated with the book. I’m going to pass but thank you so much for this very in depth review Lynn.

    • I rated it where I did because, despite my issues, I think the author shows promise and it’s not a terrible book. The characters are fully-fleshed, the general plot just fine and the writing technically decent. He just needs some experience and a good editor to avoid the mistakes made here, assuming he grows as a writer. My opinion, anyway.

  • Lynn, I agree with you absolutely that the author’s subsequent efforts will certainly be worth looking out for, I’m really disappointed in Dreamspinner for publishing this book as is. There was a fun story in there, but it’s hard to enjoy for the reasons you mention.
    It also didn’t help that I bought “Admit One” at the same time – the comparison wasn’t flattering.

    • GR, I LOVED Admit One (reviewed here), so I hear you. And I agree that as I was reading TSotSC I had wondered how DSP let this one go as is. We’ve debated here over the last several years about how it was the “go to” pub for very high quality work, but now that isn’t the case.

    • Hi Helena. I think Mactire wrote a pretty good book overall, so I have hopes that he’ll get better with time, experience and a tighter editing process.

    • Thanks for mentioning that Anke. Those hit me as well and I just forgot to mention it. I updated the review to include it.

  • Aunt Lynn, I just purchased this book this morning over at the rainbow ebook site since they are having a 20% off all dreamspinner press books through the weekend. I wish I had read your review before I bought it, because I think I would have passed on this one. Over descriptive is a turn off for me too. I don’t need 6 pages of describing what’s on the dinner table to eat. I’m still gonna read it, and I’ll let you know what I think. 🙂


Please comment! We'd love to hear from you.

%d bloggers like this: