Death by Silver (Julian Lynes and Ned Mathey #1)

death-by-silver_200x300Title: Death by Silver
Authors: Melissa Scott,
Amy Griswold
Artwork: Ben Baldwin
Cover and interior design: Alex Jeffers
Publisher: Lethe Press
Amazon: Buy Link Death by Silver
Genre: Historical/Fantasy/Murder mystery
Length: novel/272pages/110 K words
Rating: 5 stars out of 5


Review Summary: Death by Silver is magical in more ways than one – an enthralling murder mystery with suspense and romance rolled into a fantastical Victorian London. I was definitely enchanted.

The Blurb:

His practice newly established, metaphysician Ned Mathey can’t afford to turn away any clients. But the latest Londoner to seek Ned’s magical aid gives him pause: Mr Edgar Nevett, an arrogant banker, is the father of the bully who made Ned’s life hell at boarding school. Nevertheless, Ned accepts the commission to ensure the Nevett family silver bears no ancient or modern curses, and then prepares to banish the Nevett family to unpleasant memory again. Until Edgar Nevett is killed by an enchanted silver candlestick—one of the pieces Ned declared magically harmless.

Calling on his old school friend Julian Lynes—private detective and another victim of the younger Nevett—Ned races to solve the murder, clear the stain on his professional reputation, and lay to rest the ghosts of his past.

Assisted by Ned’s able secretary Miss Frost, who has unexpected metaphysical skills of her own, Ned and Julian explore London’s criminal underworld and sodomitical demimonde, uncover secrets and scandals, confront the unexpected murderer and the mysteries of their own relationship.

In Death by Silver veteran authors Melissa Scott and Amy Griswold introduce a Victorian London where magic works, influencing every aspect of civilized life, and two very appealing detectives.

Julian Lynes and Ned Mathey Series

The Review

Despite his misgivings and nightmarish memories about the horrible physical abuse he suffered at the hands of Victor Nevett, a bully who attended the same boarding school he did years ago, metaphysician Ned Mathey accepted an assignment from Victor’s father because he couldn’t afford not to, having only recently set up his practice and little money was coming in to pay the bills. When he arrived at the Nevett house, his client asked Ned to remove a curse from his impressive silver collection. Although Ned tested the various silver pieces he could find no evidence of a curse or enchantment, but he cleansed all the silver and his client seemed satisfied. However, shortly after, Mr. Nevett was found dead in his study, murdered by a heavy silver candlestick that was cursed.

With his reputation somewhat tarnished, Ned was gratified when he was asked to help Scotland Yard investigate the murder and he recommended that his old school friend (and recent secret f**k buddy), private detective Julian Lynes assist him on the case. Once the investigation got going bodies started piling up and our daring duo found it difficult to figure out the perpetrator among the many clues, suspects and red herrings. To complicate matters even further, Victor Nevett hired Ned to find out who murdered his father, as the entire family was under suspicion and he wanted to clear their names. But before the detectives reached any conclusions Victor dropped his own bombshell which made it extremely difficult for Ned, and especially Julian, to decide whether they should aggressively continue following up on leads which could conceivably free someone they hated with a passion, or they could look the other way and let the murderer get away with his crimes.

The prose, dialogue and atmosphere in Death by Silver were wonderfully crafted and this riveting adventure/mystery was highlighted by characters who were all well drawn, even the lowly under-house maids and kitchen maids merited attention from the authors. There was so much in the book that set it apart, and the detail was incredible, down to the agony columns in the newspapers that Julian scanned several times a day looking for clues and work. Miss Frost, Ned’s assistant, was not only three dimensional but, contrary to the way women were portrayed in historical books as only being interested in getting married, having babies and managing their husbands’ households, she was extremely intelligent, resourceful and a skilled investigator in her own right.

The two protagonists were not the kind of men you would likely meet in historical books set in Victorian London even though their speech, clothing, food and entertainment were consistent with the times. Gay sex was openly practised  within select groups without fear of being betrayed, and Ned and Julian frequently spent the night in each other’s rooms under the not so watchful eyes of their landladies. Of course since this is a romance there were the usual misunderstandings and hurt feelings around what each man ultimately wanted from their relationship, and how romance vs sex would play into its resolution.

Magic was everywhere and I enjoyed watching Ned work his way through the investigation using his metaphysical skills, with Julian’s detection ability contributing handsomely. This is definitely not your mother’s Victorian London as metaphysics (or magic) is used as an aid for everything from hangovers to housework! There was even a carnivorous plant that loved bacon, and Julian spent a lot of time feeding it. 🙂

I had never read any books by either Melissa Scott or Amy Griswold and what a great treat Death by Silver turned out to be – I had stopped reading historical romances a few years ago but this writing duo may make me return if they write a sequel. I initially wanted to read Silver because of the mystery but became enthralled with the characters, the vivid atmosphere and worldbuilding of Victorian London in an alternate fantasy world and two MCs who were original, very unusual and engaging. Death by Silver is a rich mystery/romance with two  protagonists who kept me engaged throughout, and if at times the prose was a little detailed I was never tempted to skip ahead.  I can’t say enough about how impressed I was by this story.

If you’re looking for a superb tale told by two talented writers who drew their characters lovingly, I would strongly recommend that you try Death by Silver which has everything you could possibly want: a solid mystery, superb world building, magic used in ways you could not imagine, two friends  on the way to becoming lovers while engaged in trying to expose a murderer on a killing spree, not to mention that some of their helpers were also criminals. What more could you possibly want? In some ways the denouement reminded me of Sherlock Holmes or Hercule Poirot and I absolutely loved how the case was resolved..



  • I just finished the book and it was simply outstanding. So very unique in a sea of sameness. I was immediately engrossed and it kept my attention the entire time. Just wonderful. I held off reading your great review until I was done and I agree with everything you said.

    Now I have to finish a review for a mediocre book that had the great misfortune to be read right before this one. *sigh*

    • Hi Lynn

      I’m so happy you enjoyed this book as much as I did. You know I very rarely read historical romances now. They seem to stress hangings and I don’t appreciate some of the language. This book was outstanding and I picked up a couple more by Melissa Scott so you may see one or two more reviews of her books. 🙂

      I know what you mean by mediocre books. 😮 🙁 I read lots of those, which is why this one was such a treat.

  • I just bought this a few days ago, and this makes me even more eager to get to it (wish my current read weren’t such a slog! I’ve got other books to get to, jeez!)

    • Hi Riga

      I really hope you enjoy this book. I haven’t read a historical or even a fantasy historical in a long time so this was such a pleasant surprise to find all of the concepts turned on their ear by a pair of such talented writers.

  • This sounds good! I’ve downloaded an excerpt, and will try to read it soon. Too much stuff happening in my life at the moment. I’m looking forward to reading it, though.

    • Gaye
      I don’t think you will regret getting this book because it’s entertaining on every level and the characters will stay with you for a long time.

    • It was wonderful Steve. I absolutely loved it and all the characters. Now I’m off to check out your site for other books by these authors. 😆 I’m up for West Hollywood but you keep saying that you’re too old for jaunts like that. :blush:

  • Wow, this must’ve been really good for you to read 272 pages! 😮
    All kidding aside Wave, you did an outstanding job on the review. Your passion comes shining through, and I can see how the story grabbed you. I do enjoy historicals too, so I’ll have to squeeze this in somewhere. So you’re next review will be a pint sized story to balance things out, right? :hysterics:

    • Hi Tj
      It really was that good and I didn’t realize it was 272 pages and 110 K words until I started to write the review and checked the word and page count. 😯 Needless to say, I was horrified 😆 I really urge you to buy this book because I believe you would absolutely love it – just remember it’s in an alternate world, so although Victorian London seems the same, everything is completely different and turned upside down.

      I haven’t read a “leaflet” in a while so I’m about due. 😀

  • I loved that book. I knew that Melissa Scott is a superb storyteller, so I grabbed it and her coauthor did not disappoint either. I loved the world building – love that historical and magical blended so well making a great fantasy. Really enjoyed that they actually investigated mystery – worked for the solution. Misunderstanding was annoying – not because it was silly, I thought it made sense for them to have the worries they did. No, I was kind of not sure if I could buy that considering that they are such good friends and never stopped being good friends even when they were not lovers, I was not sure I could buy that they would be not talking to each other about what was bothering them. Makes sense? if they were not as close, I would have thought it made more sense, but I went along with it. Great review Wave.

    • You have the advantage of me Sirius, having read books by Melissa Scott before. I went into Death by Silver blind, not knowing what to expect since I don’t read reviews on Amazon if I’m going to review a book and to say I was more than pleasantly surprised would be a huge understatement.

      Re your comment about the misunderstanding, as you know I abhor the Big Misunderstanding but I didn’t feel that this resembled that in any way. IMO Julian was under the mistaken impression that Ned was bi and only using him until he could find a suitable woman to marry since he had no reason to think otherwise because Ned was frequently in the company of women. Ned didn’t know that Julian really wanted him in more than his bed as he had other “friends”. Also, as you know men don’t talk about their “feelings” since it’s not considered manly, especially in Victorian times. Consequently I could see how this misunderstanding occurred. Anyway that’s my take on it. Other than a few slow spots I really enjoyed this book.

      • I think you are right actually – you phrased it better than me. It was a lack of communication rather than misunderstanding . The only reason I thought they should have talked is because they were so close – otherwise I would not blinked an eye. But I let it go – everything was so very good – characters, story, everything. I think you may enjoy Point series she did with Lisa Barnett ( all but the last one I think, because Lisa Barnett died). Also great mystery, fantasy world building is phenomenal and not explicit gay romance but very sweet. I reviewed either one or two books in these series and really should review whatever is left when I come back from vacations. I am not recommending Steel Blue series because it is not m/m but it is an awesome Indiana Jones like adventure. There is non explicit m/f romance there so you probably won’t like it and there is a brief mention of m/m/f ménage but only mention – it was in the past and no sex.

        • Whether it’s a lack of communication or a misunderstanding or the stars did not align properly, I don’t think the misunderstanding was anywhere close to a BM. IMO when the guys realized that they wanted to be together they resolved the commitment issue fairly quickly.

          I’ll check out the Point series on Amazon. I don’t care if the gay romance is not explicit – for me sometimes it’s better because the sex in a lot of M/M books is boring – not all, but enough to make me skip them.


Please comment! We'd love to hear from you.


I live in Canada and I love big dogs, music, movies, reading and sports - especially baseball
%d bloggers like this: