The Dark Farewell

Title: The Dark Farewell
Author: Josh Lanyon
Publisher: Self Published
Buy link: (Second Edition)
Genre: Historical M/M, murder/mystery
Length: Novella (94 pages)
Rating: 4.75 stars out of 5


Don’t talk to strangers, young man—especially the dead ones.      

It’s the Roaring Twenties. Skirts are short, crime is rampant and booze is in short supply. Prohibition has hit Little Egypt, where newspaperman David Flynn has come to do a follow-up story on the Herrin Massacre. The massacre isn’t the only news in town though.      

Spiritualist medium Julian Devereux claims to speak to the dead—and he charges a pretty penny for it. Flynn knows a phoney when he sees one, and he’s convinced Devereux is as fake as a cigar store Indian. But the reluctant attraction he feels for the deceptively soft, not-his-type Julian is as real as it gets. Suddenly Julian begins to have authentic, bloodstained visions of a serial killer, and the cynical Mr. Flynn finds himself willing to defend Julian with not only his life, but his body.      


It’s 1922. David Flynn was a tough reporter who believed in facts. When he arrived in Herrin aka Little Egypt to visit Amy, the widow of his old friend Gus whom he had not seen since Gus’s death, his purpose was to write a story one year after the murders of 21 Lester Mine Company strikebreakers. The murderers, all of whom were miners with strong Union ties, had been acquitted twice, shocking everyone, and the Crown had not pursued any further trials because it was clear that the verdict would be the same. Rough justice! No one in Little Egypt wanted to talk about the murders – they were only interested in Prohibition. The ministers were in bed with the KKK to lobby the government to stop the bootleggers and their roadhouses. It seemed all of these law abiding people felt that the Ku Klux Klan was their only solution to stopping the bootleggers who were doing a thriving business, but those same law abiding folks enjoyed the roadhouses that they were demanding publicly should be shut down. Who would have thought that in those times the KKK had legitimacy and its members were actually welcomed by the people of Herrin? Flynn’s assignment to write about the strikebreakers’ murders which seemed straightforward enough when he set out from New York, paled in comparison to a much bigger emerging story, that of several ritualistic murders of young women by a serial killer.      

On the surface Julian Devereux was the typical charlatan who pretended to talk to the dead and charged a  pretty penny for his sold-out performances every night at the Opera House where he was billed as The Magnificent Belloc. Most of the locals believed in him because once in a while he came up with unbelievable and insightful predictions that later proved to be true. The first time Flynn saw Julian at Amy’s boarding house he wanted no part of him, but Julian’s feelings were quite the opposite – he made it clear that he knew Flynn was gay and he wanted him. David and another temporary resident, a travelling medical supplies salesman named Casey Lee were attracted to each other, even spending an evening together at one of the despised roadhouses and having some fun of the carnal kind later. However this didn’t last long because David was drawn to Julian despite his better judgment; he couldn’t resist that effeminate body and those eyes which called to something in him in the wasteland of Little Egypt, a place where they could be tarred and feathered or worse for expressing their feelings for each other. As they spent more time together David realized that he was falling in love with a man whose career he loathed, but the man was so defenseless that he could not resist him. In the midst of their brief affair the murders continued to unfold on a parallel track.

As always, Josh Lanyon’s characters are the strength of his stories and Julian appealed to me because not only was he physically ill and thus vulnerable to his grandfather, a scoundrel and crook who used him for his own purposes, but he showed unexpected strength and courage at times and had no difficulty pursuing David when his attentions seemed to be unwelcome. He was illiterate because his very educated grandfather refused to have him schooled in the basics of reading and writing and stole all the money he made from his appearances as The Magnificent Belloc so he had very few, if any, options to change the direction of his life.  He had no one to represent his interests other than David Flynn who was conflicted for many reasons, including the fact that spiritualism was a foreign concept to him and also because exposure of their affair could have horrible consequences. David was a very different character to Julian, he was from a well off family, with a college degree that led to a career in journalism. He had been in the armed forces and fought in the war where he had fallen in love with another soldier named Paul who was shot to death, and he had not recovered from the tragedy when he met Julian. Conflicting loyalties to Paul and his unwanted feelings for Julian made him pursue Casey Lee who looked a bit like Paul,but any hopes of erasing Julian didn’t work so he had to adjust his disbelief in Julian’s abilities as a medium.  

I must admit that I had a bit of difficulty with some aspects of the plot especially the big reveal, not because it wasn’t plausible or I didn’t guess the murderer because the clues were there, but the end was unexpectedly abrupt and violent and while it didn’t seem logical to me it did make sense in a weird sort of way.  I can’t say much more because of spoilers but perhaps you will understand my comments after you read the book. There were many characters thrown into the mix to confuse the unwary amateur sleuth which is always a lot of fun, and when the murderer is revealed you will either say “I knew it all along” or slap yourself for not being smart enough to figure it out. Selfishly, I prefer Josh Lanyon’s murder mysteries to be novel length which provides more time for plot and character development – compressing all the information and action into a 94 page novella seemed to lose something in the final sequences even though they were exciting.

The Dark Farewell is a very enjoyable tale and whether or not you’re a fan of this author it will keep you on the edge of your seat as more women are murdered and the clues seem to lead nowhere. Spiritualism is a new area for Lanyon so fans will have something different to explore as David struggles with his skepticism about fakery and his emerging belief that Julian could be the real deal. Definitely recommended!

The Dark Farewell is available from Samhain Publishing on March 5



  • Hi Wave, loved your review! You know I show up cos I’ve just finished the book myself. *don’t throw books at me*

    I find the story a riveting read, not so much for the mystery part, but the characters are all so well-drawn and interesting – even the humble Amy! I also enjoy reading that period a lot. I stopped in the middle to read more about Herrin Massacre before I went back to the story, absolutely hollowing, and it adds extra sinister and tragic feeling to the story.

    i love the romance between Julian and David… I thought by the time David figured out Julian would be alright living in Greenwich with him, I could see Julian’s grandfather would be taken out of the picture. I don’t find the ending abrupt, but the violence did shock me and not unlike waking up from a nightmare! 🙂

    • Hi Eve
      I knew you would show up later rather than sooner – I know better than to expect you when I post the reviews. 🙂

      I knew nothing about the Herrin Massacre until I read the book and I still can’t believe that no one was held accountable for the crimes. Even for those times it makes me sad that 21 people were murdered and no one cared. 🙁

      I loved the romance between David and Julian who was my favourite character, and while the history was well researched in the book I’m not so much of a history buff as I am a murder mystery fan. I knew Josh said that the murders weren’t as much the focus of the book but it was still riveting.

      I’m glad you liked the review. Shall I pencil you in for a week after the next review? 🙂

  • Josh
    Thank you for responding to all the amateur sleuths, writers and psychoanalysts 🙂 on this site. As you can tell, we disect a lot of books by trying to figure out the writers’ intentions and we have a great time, whether or not we’re right or wrong.

    I appreciate you indulging us by responding to the comments now that the book has been read. While the historical aspect was important, as you figured out, the murders were what really got my attention.

    I don’t read a lot of ghost stories so I had no idea that the ending in the Dark Farewell was true to the ghost stories of that period which is why I was surprised. I learn something new every day.

    I obviously had a great time with the murders but I loved Julian’s characterization even more than Flynn’s.

    Thanks again for dropping by Josh. Much appreciated. Oh yes, later today Randy the randomizer will announce the name of the winner of The Dark Farewell. We all apreciate you making your books available as free books on the site and there’s always moaning and gnashing of teeth from the losers. 🙂

  • Liade
    This is what I meant about how we all take away different things when we read a book, and The Dark Farewell does resonate or we wouldn’t be discussing it.

    I thought that the murders were the focus because I love murder mysteries, regardless whether the story is set in historical times or is contemporary. The fact that no one was held accountable for the murders and no one cared seemed callous, but then this was a heavily unionized area and they hated the strike breakers; also from all accounts the owner of the mine was a horrible man.

    From my perspective Julian stole the story from Flynn despite the fact he was uneducated and physically frail, but that’s just me, always rooting for the underdog. 🙂

  • Hi Merith
    You know, most everyone I talk to about this book (those who have read it of course) have a different impression about what the story is really all about. I guess it goes to show what an incredible writer Josh Lanyon is. I love murder mysteries so I focused on that aspect of the book, some reviewers love the historical aspect so that was where their interest lay etc. etc.

    It’s interesting that you thought it was a story about Flynn and probably that was because although the book wasn’t 1st person POV it was all mostly from Flynn’s perspective. I liked Julian’s character because he was so vulnerable, physically and mentally, and he really was the catalyst for Flynn’s evolution as you mentioned. 🙂

    • That is an interesting observation! I can understand how people can and do focus on different aspects of a story that align more to their interests.

      I wonder if Josh would be up to giving a little insight on what he was aiming for with this story. Probably all factors making up the story, just to give everyone something to talk about. 🙂

      One of the elements in the story that really made me ponder was the massacre and the common attitude surrounding it. The psychology of a mob mentality, but it’s not really that either. Because there was so much behind what led to the massacre the impulse to excuse the murders is there. At the same time, the lack of accountability is like the elephant in the room no one wants to directly address, but the worn groove around the elephant stands out very clearly.

      You are right, though. There is no one like Josh to bring us the best in his style, his genre.

      • Merith

        I wonder if Josh would be up to giving a little insight on what he was aiming for with this story. Probably all factors making up the story, just to give everyone something to talk about. <<

        I sent Josh an email and if he’s around I’m sure he will add his point of view, being suitably mysterious of course. 🙂

        At the same time, the lack of accountability is like the elephant in the room no one wants to directly address, but the worn groove around the elephant stands out very clearly. <<

        That struck me as well which is why I mentioned it in the review. 21 people murdered and no one was held accountable. I guess it was a sign of the times and indeed was rough justice.

        • I went back to the journal entry Josh made last October about the history behind the story. The Herrin massacre really did happen just as Josh wrote. There were a lot of extenuating circumstances behind the murders, though it doesn’t excuse what happen. It makes me wonder if anyone has done a psychological look at the times and the mindset of those involved.

          Which brings me to another theme in Josh’s other recent release. “The Dark Tide” theme where there are people who would normally be honest law-abiding and moral but some situations or circumstances will override what they’d normally do/say/think into something monstrous. I would like to think that the conditions the miners and their families went through brought about their actions, and the county and those involved were swept away on their own dark tide.


Please comment! We'd love to hear from you.


I live in Canada and I love big dogs, music, movies, reading and sports - especially baseball
%d bloggers like this: