Gives Light

Title: Gives Light (Gives Light series)
Author: Rose Christo
Cover artist: n/a
Publisher: Self
Amazon: Buy Link Gives Light (Gives Light Series)
Genre: YA romance
Length: 315 pages
Rating: 5 stars out of 5

A guest review by Sirius

Summary:  A memorable narrator and great writing made for a fantastic read for me.

Blurb:

“Skylar is my name, tragically.”

Sixteen-year-old Skylar is witty, empathetic, sensitive–and mute. Skylar hasn’t uttered a single word since his mother died eleven years ago, a senseless tragedy he’s grateful he doesn’t have to talk about.
When Skylar’s father mysteriously vanishes one summer afternoon, Skylar is placed in the temporary custody of his only remaining relative, an estranged grandmother living on an Indian reservation in the middle of arid Arizona.

Adapting to a brand new culture is the least of Skylar’s qualms. Because Skylar’s mother did not die a peaceful death. Skylar’s mother was murdered eleven years ago on the Nettlebush Reserve. And her murderer left behind a son.

And he is like nothing Skylar has ever known.

Review:

As some of you may know by now I love Young Adult coming of age stories. I have read many good ones, but this one  I would characterize as wonderful. I am actually really frustrated again because the usual description of what this story is about would  apply to so many “coming of age” books. It is a story about growing up, about finding your place in the world, about coming to terms with your heritage, coming to terms with the fact that you are attracted to men.

But this description will also make this story sound like a  cookie cutter one and it  is so far from being  a cookie cutter. I probably should stop being frustrated again that the story fits its subgenre so perfectly and tell you guys why it feels so different, so wonderful, so unique to me. I suppose great writing has something to do with all of that and with how the narrator is portrayed. Skylar is such a great protagonist, his voice is both vulnerable and strong and so very sixteen. It is ironic that I was so in love with his voice, because as the blurb tells you Skylar lost his voice because of violence that took place years ago.

“I smiled slightly and shook my head. It was ironic that he’d called the cat clock creepy, because he looked like a timid  kitten right now and it was adorable. I hate using  words like adorable, but there was no other word for it.

I kissed him on the nose.

There was something I really liked about …. (name omitted for spoilerish purposes :)) nose. I don’t know what it was. The shape definitely factored into it, but … now that I think about it, it’s probably just that it happened to be in the center of his face. I liked his face on the whole. I liked everything about him. It was a little scary to realize there was absolutely nothing about him I found unpleasant”

I do not remember ever reading a book in this genre which takes place in a contemporary Indian Reservation (I have read a couple where the events took place in the past), but while the  setting adds charm to the story, it was very far from being its main attraction to me. I think I was reminded of the suggestion that interesting characters could be interesting in any time and place and every person in this story was interesting.

Skylar tells the story and you can imagine him sitting near you and telling you all of this, if  he could talk. You can see his father, his grandmother, kids, teenagers with whom Skylar becomes friends so clearly in front of your eyes.

The blurb hints at Skylar getting to know the son of his mother’s murderer and it is indeed true,  but do not expect  this plot development to b e any kind of sensationalism. When  I started reading the story I was worried that this revelation will come up as a source for potential conflict because at first it will be a secret and then it will come up in the most unexpected way. Well, it was not like that at  all and  I counted my blessings that the writer did not handle it in the way the secrets are so often being handled in romance.   And that is all I am going to say on this matter 😉

I also have to say that the romance felt so beautiful, genuine and believable to me and this is all I am going to say on this matter as well, because the blurb is quite silent on the matter of Skylar’s love interest.

I do have to say that the resolution of the events from the past did bother me; not in the sense that it did not fit the story, it just bothered me on the personal level, but I am not sure how it could have been done any differently.

This first book can be read as a stand alone, but you can see that there are issues which will continue in the next two books which I have not read yet and  I believe the author promised a fourth book as a  free conclusion to the trilogy.

Highly recommended.

16 comments

  • I loved this book, it felt so original and has an outstanding emotional resonance beyond the lovely romance.

    The other books in the series are perhaps a tiny bit flawed for me in terms of repetition and an unnecessary storyline, but in another important way they made a huge impression.

    I was so moved and made angry by the problems the characters faced and then to read about the reality of the situation was shocking. I found the social realism of the final book which is set when the boys are adults incredibly upsetting.

    Thank you so much for the very fervent recommendation Sirius. I won’t forget this book.

    Reply
    • I still cannot forget this book and I completely agree about the social realism. So glad this recommendation worked for you. 😀

      Reply
  • Sounds great – I checked to make sure it’s on the bookshelf for the YA LGBT group, and it looks like there are two more in this series. Definitely something I’ll want to read.

    Reply
    • There are two more books in the trilogy yes and couple days ago the author put the free fourth one on Smashwords, it is 99 cents on Amazon :). I have not read them yet, because I heard from friends who did that while the books are also very good, they are a touch more flawed than the first one. And I wanted to review the whole trilogy, but now I am trying to decide whether I even want to look for flaws after the first book affected me so much, you know?

      So I guess I will get to them after I decide for sure whether I will be reviewing the rest of trilogy or not, and that will be a factor as to how I will be reading them. I really want to close my eyes and ignore whatever flaws could be there. But in any event my friends who read them enjoyed the next two books as well.

      I hope you like them too Kaje.

      Reply
  • This sounds great, thanks for the rec! 😀

    And I know what you mean about feeling uncomfortable recommending a book too strongly, because then what if the other person doesn’t like it? 😮 That said, I do hope you’ll read An Immovable Solitude (or at least, read it if I love this one), since that’s one of the best books I’ve read this year. 🙂

    Reply
    • I will, as soon as it appears on Amazon I will get it :-). I went to get it just now and it is not there yet, so as soon as it is, I am clicking the button lol.

      Let me know what you thought of Gives Light.

      Reply
  • “Well, it was not like that at all and I counted my blessings that the writer did not handle it in the way the secrets are so often being handled in romance. ”

    I love that the author avoided a BM! That alone makes me want to get this book. I really enjoy reading about Native Americans too, but as you say most stories are historical rather than contemporary, so that’s a real draw for me as well. Thanks for the review Sirius. Great job as usual – especially managing to not give out spoilers.

    Reply
  • This sounds really good. I usually like the books you recommend, Sirius, so I’m going to give this one a go. It’s a good price at Smashwords, too.

    Reply
    • Gay, you know I am rarely persistent in recommending the books (feel like it is too much pressure if I insisted and person did not like the book), but when I sent email to Raine about this book (we often recommend books to each other :-)), it sounded something like this:

      READ IT!!! Okay, maybe it was in the lower case and one exclamation point, but you get the jist 🙂

      I do not feel like my review did a justice to this book at all, I feel like it was in the top five best books I have read this year.

      Read it, I will take the blame if you hate it, but I think this book is worthy of a chance 🙂 It is a good price on amazon as well.

      There are two more books in the series, but if you hate this one, it does not end with the cliffhanger at all. There is also a free story which serves as conclusion, but I guess that makes it fourth book lol.

      Reply
      • I really did like this series of stories. It’s one of those times when the characters stay with me long after I’ve finished reading.

        I was interested in learning about the Indian way of life on reservations, which was sometimes shocking. I am amazed that kidnapping of Indian children still takes place.

        I hope Rose writes more stories similar to these, because her style of writing is addictive. Skylar is a wonderful narrative voice.

        Reply
        • YAY, you liked these books Gay, am so happy :). I absolutely agree that she has an addictive writing style and wish she would write more.

          Reply

Please comment! We'd love to hear from you.

%d bloggers like this: